Çağatay Yılmaz and Henrik Barestrand from the Swedish RISE Institute on the EU Energy Efficiency Directive
How can RISE bridge the gap between academia and industry? What are the current trends in sustainable digitalization? How should sustainability indicators be used in data centers? We talked to Çağatay Yılmaz, Project Manager of ICE Data Centre (RISE) and Henrik Barestrand at the HEATWISE Meetup in Budapest.
Can you say a few words about the role of the RISE Institute in the HEATWISE project? What are you doing in Sweden and how do you cooperate with the other project partners?
CY: From Sweden: RISE is owned by the Swedish government. We are trying to bridge the gap between academia and industry. Basically, we try to increase the level of technology readiness with open innovation practices. We work with organizations and help them to make sure that their products are ready for market and comply with standards.
The RISE Research Institute is quite a large organization: we have 3,300 people. Our unit where I work, ICE Data Center, is located up north in the city of Luleå. ICE Data Center focuses on sustainable digitalization with a focus on data centers. This is our role in the HEATWISE project too. I could say that we represent the data center business. But this project isn’t just about data centers, it’s about decarbonizing buildings in general. So, there are other partners in the collaboration that represent building sites, that deal with management communication.
HB: What we’re doing is helping companies develop products. Start-ups for example, big companies, research departments. We collaborate with a lot of companies. The principle is that we support their research departments. Let’s say there’s a startup company with a product, and we’re evaluating that product in the context of data centers as well. We help them develop the technology, like what we have done in the HETAWISE project.

Let us move away from the HEATWISE project for a moment! You mentioned in your presentation that one of your focus areas is sustainable digitalization. Can you name some of the main trends or focus areas in sustainable digitalization? What can be said about this area today?
CY: The EU wants to decarbonize industry. I don’t think they prioritized data centers before, but now they understand that they are responsible for a lot of energy consumption. And it is not just data centers, but all sorts of digital technologies that are spreading around the world. Think of your fridge and probably even your vacuum cleaner: they are all smart now. These technologies need to be more sustainable. We focus more on the cloud side, where the data from the Internet of Things (IoT) is collected. But the EU has just pointed out that this is a risk.
One of the main trends is to reduce the carbon footprint of these digital technologies. This is why the EU, for example, supports the refurbishment of digital technologies. The key words here are repair and reuse. Another example is when they forced Apple to use USB-C instead of their own plugs; the aim was that we should be able to use all the adapters in all our devices and we can only buy one adapter. Such initiatives or actions have been taken on the IoT side of the digital continuum.
But we are now talking about a slightly different story, about energy-intensive industries. I can give you an example. A rack as big as this table can now reach up to 200, 300 kilowatts. That is huge when you consider that a boiler that is not running all day is about 2 kilowatts. Now the EU wants us to focus on this, to make these systems more efficient, but most importantly to reuse the waste heat from these energy-intensive IT gadgets. That way the whole energy consumption is reduced. If we reuse the waste heat, edge data centers can replace the boilers in the buildings. So it would be a win-win situation. This is the only way to achieve climate neutrality in the long term.
And now there are a variety of markets that need this waste heat and with this HEATWISE project we are trying to look at different use cases. Rasmus can give you more information about how you can use this, use this waste heat in greenhouses, in factories, in commercial buildings, everything. They all need different heat loads.
HB: What we’re doing is evaluating new technologies and putting them in the context of the data center. And what we’re trying to achieve is this energy harmony between all the players. Imagne the compute cloud where we have big players like banks, medical services, everything. Perhaps in the future we can enable them to put some of the work load on local servers in small communities and have it be beneficial for everyone, instead of exclusively having big data centers outside the cities. In that way, we are looking at ways to integrate it into city systems for heating.

CY: I can give another example. I think this might be useful. Imagine you have a fleet of cars. 10 cars and you have a parcel delivery company with those 10 cars. It is similar with data centers and our infrastructure. Depending on how much load you put on them, they have a consumption profile, in this case fuel and power consumption profile. Even if your car is not going anywhere, but the engine is running, it still consumes energy. In the data center world, 30% of peak energy consumption can be in standby mode.
Smart workload orchestration and intelligent use of your infrastructure can deliver huge energy efficiency benefits. Up to a certain point, the way we use this infrastructure hardware is like the way you use your personal computer. But with computing clouds, we started to virtualize it. That was a big step in the industry. It brought a lot of efficiency because multiple users could connect to one piece of hardware, they started using it. That is multi-tenancy and that is so important. But now we are always trying to go one step further. We are trying to do a better job of orchestrating and managing the IT infrastructure and extending the efficiencies that we bring to the market. This is one of the things we are trying to do in the HEATWISE project and more generally in our own ICE Data Center.
You mentioned EU Energy Efficiency Directive in your presentation. Can you summarize it in a few sentences?
CY: I believe that data center owners or operators are only interested in one thing: uptime. I’m not criticizing their motives. They don’t want their critical infrastructure to fail because we depend on these systems. Think of an air traffic control company or local authorities. If we were not within reach of these digital systems, we would be in trouble. We could survive without these digital systems before, but not now. We are dependent on them because we have automated a lot of our operations. The owners and operators of data centers have built an ecosystem that is only focused on not having downtime when we can’t reach the applications or services.
If we do not force the market to innovate while also caring about uptime, I guarantee you that no one will do anything about sustainability and efficiency. If I was the IT manager of the ICE Data Centre, I wouldn’t care how much energy I use. My job is uptime, to keep the data center running.
EU has taken an initiative, the first step towards a more sustainable future. Many of us have discussed whether it’s a good initiative or not. This is a competitive market, and we are competing with global players like the US and China, Japan and South Korea. If you think about our competitiveness with these markets, a new challenge of efficiency measures in the market raised a lot of question marks, no doubt. But I think we had to take this action. Now it’s going to be more difficult for us because we’re getting out of our comfort zone. We have to change; we have to be more competitive. But in the long term, I believe that European companies that have adapted to the European Energy Efficiency Directive and tried to introduce more efficient products can have a competitive advantage over other competitors from other markets. This is a good thing. You see, I’m trying to see the whole picture. I’m trying to motivate myself and the market that this initiative should have been taken.
In your presentation, you also discussed sustainability indicators for data centers. What do you think about them? Is there one universal indicator that could show everything, or do you believe in a combination of KPIs?
CY: Is there an all-encompassing formula that covers all aspects of efficiency? Like the theory of everything, a single line that explains everything. I think there is no such line, because there are different aspects in data centers. You can improve one KPI but ruin the rest. You can improve one KPI, but in doing so you may reduce the lifetime of the products, so you end up with higher carbon emissions with the embedded carbon of the new products you get. Unfortunately, the solution is not that simple. When I first started working with data centers, PUE was the first KPI I was introduced to. And in one of the meetings I had, I didn’t know it at the time, I met the person who wrote the European standards which adopted PUE. And I started complaining about it. I said this is nonsense, we cannot just adapt one KPI or base the whole strategy on one KPI. I think this document should be improved. He said: “Can you elaborate on that? Because I wrote this document. You can imagine that I started to sweat. But it turned out really good. We discussed it and decided that if we want to see overall efficiency, we have to look at several key performance indicators at the same time.
When you go to the doctor, he or she will not just give you a pill. First, he or she tries to understand what you need. What are the symptoms, what is the problem. It’s the same with data centers and infrastructure: it depends on the size, what grid you’re going to connect it to, if you can use the waste heat and so on. The answer depends on the conditions and infrastructure.
In terms of individual KPIs, to be honest, I am not a big fan of PUE, for example, because it is not a comparative metric. You can’t compare two data centers based on their PUEs. That KPI can show you that this data center is better in terms of energy efficiency, but the same data center could be failing in all other aspects. It can be easily manipulated. For example, go into the cooling system of your data center and increase the cold aisle temperatures of the data center. What would it do? Your IT infrastructure would suffer because it wouldn’t get enough cooling, but your PUE would be perfect (closer to 1). You would be sending more energy to IT because the computers would be using the internal fans and trying to fight it off.
I believe that every infrastructure is an individual and the teams that run the data center should know what they are doing and have a master plan to improve overall efficiency. HB: There is a story about how data centers have evolved from the beginning. I think in the past, cooling was the main issue with them, because cooling itself consumed a lot of energy. So, the PUE number used to have a specific purpose: to show the efficiency of the cooling. But that purpose is now better applied combined with other KPIs. If you were building a new data centre and you wanted it to be sustainable and future-proof at EU level, you would also need other KPIs for this reason. So, like in this project, we’re looking at a lot of KPIs. And maybe we will discover relationships between the different KPIs, and perhaps find something that can be simpler or something that needs to be considered more in context of performance. I think we will also learn a lot from this project.








